Tag: Vermilion County Sheriff

  • Hugh Sands Back on The Ballot After Judge Reverses Previous Ban

    Hugh Sands Back on The Ballot After Judge Reverses Previous Ban

    Voters in Vermilion County will have the final say on who becomes the next sheriff, thanks to a ruling by Judge Lindsey Starwalt that requires local election authorities to include Hugh Sands’ name on the ballot.

    Starwalt’s ruling reverses a November 2025 vote by the Vermilion County Electoral Board to bar Sands from the ballot, siding with complainant Jerry Hawker, who objected to Sands’ candidacy over what he called a lack of qualification.

    According to Starwalt, Sands — a retired law enforcement officer — meets Illinois statute requirements for qualification. She also ruled that, according to her interpretation of the law, candidates are not required to submit proof of qualification before the petition filing deadline, but simply a statement that they are qualified.

    Judge Rules on Submission Deadline Argument

    Under Illinois statute 55 ILCS 5/3-6001.5, anyone running for sheriff must provide “a certificate attesting to his or her successful completion of the Minimum Standards Basic Law Enforcement Officers Training Course as prescribed by the Illinois Law Enforcement Training Standards Board,” or a waiver showing their equivalent qualification.

    The Electoral Board — made up of State’s Attorney Jacqueline Lacy, Circuit Clerk Melissa Quick, and County Clerk Robyn Heffern — argued in November that Sands should not be permitted to run because he had not filed proof of the waiver before the filing deadline for election petition packets.

    “Mr. Hawker and the Board will argue that a candidate is required by statute to file their training certificate or waiver with their nomination petition,” Starwalt said Friday. “There is nothing in the statute nor case law that supports this argument.”

    Instead, Starwalt said, a candidate only has to “state whether he or she is legally qualified for the position,” which she said Sands had done when he filed an affidavit attesting to his qualifications.

    Starwalt Reverses Electoral Board’s Ruling

    The Electoral Board also argued that Sands’ waiver did not suffice for the certificate — another argument Starwalt rejected.

    Sands’ waiver met legal requirements for office, Starwalt said, because Sands had to pass an equivalency exam given by the Illinois Law Enforcement Training Standards Board — the same body that provides the required training certificate — in order to receive the waiver and work in law enforcement.

    Before his retirement, Sands had served as a correctional officer and part-time police officer for the Village of Oakwood for a combined 20 years.

    “The court finds that Mr. Sands has completed the necessary law enforcement training to fulfill the certification requirement… and is qualified to run for the office of sheriff. The decision of the electoral board is reversed, and the election authorities are directed to place Mr. Sands on the ballot,” Starwalt said.

    Legal Context & Background

    Sands was represented by attorney Jason Bartell of Bartell Powell LLP of Champaign & Bloomington.

    In Sands’ official petition for judicial review, Bartell cited the August 2022 case of Brogan v. Colatorti, in which Antonio “Tony” Colatorti’s petition to run as Sheriff of McHenry County was upheld after being challenged for the same reason as Sands.

    In that case, the court held that Colatorti was qualified for the office of sheriff, ruling that his part‑time certificate, along with the evidence of training and service, satisfied the statutory requirement for the certificate.

    Lacy had rejected the Colatorti case as a precedent in the November hearing, arguing it didn’t apply in Sands’ case. Instead, she argued that the Colatorti ruling “was not speaking about a correctional officer. That appellate court opinion is speaking specifically regarding law enforcement minimum training.”

    To substantiate the Board’s stance, Lacy instead referenced another case, that of Gercone v. Cook County Officers Electoral Board (2022). In that case, the Illinois Appellate Court ruled against Carmen Navarro Gercone’s petition to run for sheriff, saying he was unqualified.

    Lacy’s argument in that ruling was not surprising, according to Bartell, who said the Brogan case was “right on point” in relation to Sands’ case.

    “That’s what all attorneys do. That’s the art of lawyering. It’s trying to persuade [the judge/jury] that one case applies in the situation and the other case doesn’t,” he said.

    Bartell went on to say he agreed to take on Sands’ case, in part, because he wants voters to have a choice.

    “I believe in democracy and the process. And to me, it’s for the voters to decide,” Bartell said.

    Reactions to the Ruling

    When court was adjourned, Sands’ wife, Melissa, embraced him.

    “It’s a relief,” she said, wiping her eyes. “These are happy tears.”

    As for Sands, he said he feels great and plans to get going on the campaign trail.

    “Me and my wife are gonna have some discussions,” Sands said. “And yes, we’re gonna campaign. We’re gonna do it the right way.”

    Hawker was unable to attend the hearing due to a recent hospitalization, Starwalt said, adding that he had been given the option to attend via Zoom but had declined.

    “I have no problem with [the ruling] at all,” Hawker told the Vermilion Times. “The decision for me to file the objection was that he did not file any of the training [proof], and that’s what was required.”

    Hawker went on to say that he thinks perhaps Judge Starwalt may have seen the filing deadline as “only a technicality.”

    “It would have been nice if he’d filed the appropriate paperwork at the time,” Hawker said. “If he had, he could have avoided all this and saved us all a lot of wasted time.”

    According to Bartell, since the deadline to submit changes to the ballot is January 14, 2026, he doubts any new complaint will be filed against Sands, so he doesn’t believe there will be any further challenges to his candidacy.

    Early voting in Vermilion County begins February 5, 2026.