Tag: Randy Fletcher

  • New DACC Policy: Employees Can Be Punished for “Immoral, Indecent” Behavior

    New DACC Policy: Employees Can Be Punished for “Immoral, Indecent” Behavior

    DACC’s new Employee Standards Policy includes an undefined “immorality” standard, raising legal questions

    Danville Area Community College has released a new Employee Standards of Conduct policy, which prohibits employees from engaging in “immoral” or “indecent” acts.

    As to what, exactly, constitutes such acts, the policy is silent.

    Revised for the first time since 1992, the new policy applies to all employees whenever they are on college property or conducting college business off campus.

    The college is already facing an ongoing investigation by the Illinois Community College Board into allegations of misuse of funds in the Adult Education Department.

    This new policy could court more legal issues, based on Illinois legal precedent and federal employee protection laws that govern the college.

    What Is Prohibited

    Aside from banning “immoral” or “indecent” behavior, the list of conduct that can result in discipline includes:

    • Dishonesty or falsification of records
    • Theft or sabotage of college or employee property
    • Possession or use of alcohol, illegal drugs, or weapons on campus
    • Fighting or threats of violence
    • Use of profane or abusive language, including racial slurs
    • Insubordination
    • Gambling
    • Sleeping on the job
    • Unauthorized use of confidential information
    • Sexual harassment or discrimination
    • Working another job while on approved leave without prior college authorization

    The policy clarifies that DACC reserves the right to discipline employees for any conduct it deems inappropriate, including conduct not listed, as long as it is — in the college’s sole judgment — a violation of policy or an impediment to job performance.

    According to one employee, the determination of what constitutes “immoral” behavior rests entirely with DACC President Randall “Randy” Fletcher.

    Disciplinary Process & Rights

    DACC’S new employee standard policy outlines a progressive disciplinary process that can include a verbal warning, written warning, suspension with or without pay, and ultimately, termination.

    But supervisors may skip or repeat steps depending on circumstances, and certain offenses can result in immediate termination without prior warning, according to the policy.

    Employees facing suspension without pay or termination may request a hearing before the Board of Trustees within seven calendar days of receiving notice. The Board may accept, reduce, increase, or otherwise modify any recommended discipline, and its decision is final.

    The policy does include a provision stating it is not intended to interfere with employees’ rights to organize or engage in protected concerted activity under the National Labor Relations Act.

    Vague Policy Language Could Spell Legal Trouble

    The “immorality” language in the policy raises constitutional questions rooted in what legal scholars call the void-for-vagueness doctrine.

    Under the Due Process Clauses of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments, laws and policies must be written with sufficient clarity that ordinary people can understand what conduct is prohibited and that enforcement cannot be arbitrary or discriminatory.

    DACC’s policy defines “immoral conduct” nowhere. It lists no examples, references no legal standard, and ties the term to no objective criteria, leaving employees to determine on their own what conduct might cross the line.

    That concern is compounded by the fact that DACC is a public employer.

    Unlike private companies, public institutions are bound by the Constitution, and their employees retain constitutional rights as a condition of their employment.

    In Pickering v. Board of Education — a case that originated in Illinois — courts established that the First Amendment limits the ability of a public employer to condition employment on the forfeiture of an employee’s constitutional rights.

    A vague “immorality” clause in a public employer’s disciplinary policy could potentially be applied to protected speech, off-duty personal conduct, or associational choices. The undefined standard appears not once but twice in the revised document, in items (j) and (t).

    Under Illinois law, to deny a terminated employee unemployment benefits on misconduct grounds, an employer must prove the employee deliberately and willfully violated a reasonable workplace rule. An undefined standard of “immorality” could present challenges for the college in such proceedings.

    The Vermilion Times has reached out to DACC for comment and will update this story should we receive a response.


    As an independent, 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization, The Vermilion Times depends on donations from readers like you to keep things running.

    Even $10 a month can make this work more sustainable.