In a community where government meetings are opened with religious invocations, what does it mean when those same elected leaders ignore the poor, the marginalized, and the vulnerable? Kaighla White examines the political hypocrisy at the heart of local leadership.
Separation of Church and State? Not Quite
Based on the origin story we’ve all been taught, the United States of America was formed, in part, as a haven for religious freedom. It was for that reason the founders of the country added the Establishment Clause to the Constitution, which requires a separation of religion and The State.
Despite this, the Supreme Court ruled in 2013 that it’s perfectly legal for municipal governments to open meetings with a prayer as part of the traditional “invocation” section of the meeting.
Anyone may give the invocation, and they may pray in any manner and to any deity they like. (Check out Town of Greece v. Galloway and Williamson v. Brevard County for examples of cases when these practices were challenged and how those challenges turned out.)
That means you could call the mayor’s office at your local town hall and ask to be added to the schedule to lead the invocation, then walk into that room and pray to literally anything. Not that I’m suggesting it.
So long as leadership doesn’t discriminate in favor of or against any specific religion, it’s all good — at least on paper. In practice, it often turns into political hypocrisy cloaked in tradition.
Prayer as a way to sway a captive audience
As much as it bothers me to see the same faith represented again and again and again and again at these meetings (because there are many people of many faiths in the room), my beef isn’t with people praying to Jesus in a government meeting.
At the most recent City Council meeting on December 2, Alderwoman Carolyn DeToye said a prayer that I actually agreed with.
“Help us to remember that our calling as aldermen is to serve our people. Lord, just take our eyes off of self, off of agendas, off of anything that hampers us from doing your will and doing the will of the people,” she said.
‘Hear, hear,’ I say!
The problem comes when those same church leaders, aldermen, and other community leaders find a way to squeeze their personal agenda into the prayer, or then vote in a way that makes life that much harder for the very people in their community who need a little Christian kindness most.
We’ve all heard it: a person stands up and calls the gathered crowd to join them in prayer, then delivers a several-minute-long onslaught of their personal political agenda, either to sway their vote or their opinion one way or the other.
Sure, they say they’re addressing God/Jesus/whomever, but it’s awfully convenient that they have a captive audience forced to listen to their words.
But then, when have religion and the State not worked hand-in-hand to accomplish their goals? See The Divine Right of Kings, The Spanish Inquisition, the integral work of missionaries to further colonial expansion, Tsarist Russia and the Orthodox Church, pro-slavery theology in the Antebellum American South, Cold War anti-communism sermons, Iran’s Islamic Republic, and more.
The list really goes on and on of times when the Church used sermons to spread and reinforce ideas that served the State’s goals, which is why the founders thought it was so important to include the Establishment Clause in the Constitution.
Have You Even Met Jesus?
It’s especially disturbing when our local leaders cite Christianity for the reason they’re voting in a certain way, usually in favor of the interests of the wealthy (who are almost always white) and against the working poor (and also women, Black and brown people, queer folx, disabled folks, and minorities in general).
Citing the name of a poor, anti-establishment Jewish Palestinian from 2,000 years ago (who literally got himself killed by calling out such leaders) to justify your decision to hurt and neglect people he would have advocated for is rich, and the irony is off the scale.
Remember Alderwoman DeToye’s touching prayer I cited earlier? Let’s read another quote from DeToye regarding the homeless in Danville, one she delivered at the City Council meeting on June 3, 2025:
“There are legitimate people who need help and need your care and love. We need to help those people that are trying to help themselves, but when the help is there and they refuse that help, it’s not the city’s problem. It’s not these organizations’ problems. It’s those people’s problem. I would like to see his mission [Danville Rescue] filled every night with these people who need that help but if they refuse the help, how can you help somebody that doesn’t want to be helped?”
Had DeToye sat down and had a real conversation with someone living on the street, rather than relying on the statements from police (who have historically been on the side of the poor, right? not), she would have learned there are many valid reasons someone would “turn down” help. Like…
- Not being able to keep their family together, since the only available shelter options at the moment are separated by gender.
- Having a pet to care for, since animals aren’t allowed in homeless shelters unless they have already been registered as a support animal.
- Struggling with active drug or alcohol addiction, since the shelters in Danville have a no-tolerance policy.
- Having PTSD, being a former rape victim, surviving domestic abuse, or having other mental health issues that makes sleeping in a room full of strangers feel unsafe and panic-inducing.
And those are just a few of the reasons cited by Danville Rescue’s own director, Michael Ewing, in our interview with him.
On June 3, 2025, DeToye (then Wands) voted against delaying the vote on the ordinance to give more time to edit it fairly — time she could have used to educate herself.
She then went on to join alderpeople James Poshard, Mike O’Kane, Rick Strebing, Sharon Pickering, Eve Ludwig, Doug Ahrens, and Jon Cooper in voting in favor of the ordinance, which would have punished people for being homeless by giving them citations and fees and even jail time. (Although the ordinance had 8 votes (which would typically be enough to pass), the City’s official minutes indicate the ordinance failed.)
But DeToye asked God to guide her to serve the people, she said. I guess she only means people like her, and those who fit her narrative of the deserving poor — something Jesus never spoke about.
Hypocrisy: A Big Sin, No Matter Your Faith
Don’t get me wrong. This article isn’t intended only to call out DeToye, who claims to have spent several decades serving the needy. But the stark contrast between her prayer and her actual vote is notable.
What we’re seeing isn’t just moral failure — it’s political hypocrisy draped in religious language, and every major faith tradition warns against it.
As a former evangelical missionary, then a devout Muslim for more than a decade, I have a unique perspective on this issue. As much as these religions may seem to differ on the surface, both have a focus on helping the poor and downtrodden.
“For I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me drink… Truly I tell you, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did for me.”
– Jesus, according to the Gospel of Matthew (25:35–40)
“Righteousness is… to give wealth, in spite of love for it, to relatives, orphans, the needy, the traveler, those who ask, and to free the slaves…”
– God, in the Qur’an (2:177)
“He is not a believer whose stomach is filled while his neighbor goes hungry.”
– Prophet Muhammad (Sahih Muslim 2586)
Both religions also have some pretty harsh things to say about hypocrites who announce their religious devotion in public and then actively work against helping the weakest and most vulnerable people in the community.
“‘Depart from me, you who are cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels. For I was hungry and you gave me nothing to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me nothing to drink, I was a stranger and you did not invite me in, I needed clothes and you did not clothe me, I was sick and in prison and you did not look after me… whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for me.’”
– Jesus, according to the Gospel of Matthew (25:41–45)
“Indeed, the hypocrites will be in the lowest depths of the Fire—and you will not find for them a helper.”
– God, in the Qur’an (4:145)
Just Admit You Don’t Care About The Poor / Black / Brown / Queer / Disabled / Other
It’s not only icky to use religion to justify your actions (especially when your actions are not in line with that religion’s beliefs), it’s cowardly.
Rather than hiding behind a religion you don’t even fully understand or live by — a move that screams political hypocrisy — just say how you really feel with your whole chest: “I don’t care about how certain people could be affected by my decision.”
At least then you’ll only have to answer for your callousness when you meet your maker. Surely that’ll go over better for you than being both heartless and hypocritical.
The views expressed in this piece are solely those of the author and do not reflect any official position of The Vermilion Times or its partners. As a 501c3 tax-exempt public charity, we remain committed to offering a platform for diverse local voices while maintaining journalistic integrity and editorial independence.

About the Author
Kaighla White
Kaighla White is the Executive Director and Editor of The Vermilion Times. She is an award-winning journalist with a penchant for asking the hard questions. After a year in traditional community journalism, she said, ‘Abso-f*cking-lutely not’ and decided to go her own way.
That’s how The Vermilion Times was born.

