The Vermilion County Electoral Board voted unanimously Monday to remove Hugh Sands from the running for Vermilion County Sheriff, siding with objector Jerry Hawker.
Hawker’s objection centered on the question of whether Sands — who served for 20+ years as a part-time police officer with the Village of Oakwood as well as a full-time correctional officer at the County Jail before his retirement — was qualified to run as sheriff.
Sands’ Waiver of Certification
During opening remarks, Hawker made a point to clarify that he had filed the objection to Sands’ candidacy as a resident, not in his capacity as a County Board Member, and that he held no ill will toward Sands.
“I have known Hugh for 30 years and I consider him a friend,” Hawker said. “I only object to one thing, and that is the certification of training.”
Hawker said his primary concern was “the integrity of the ballot.”
The training certificate Hawker was referring to came about thanks to the Police Training Act, a law passed in 1965, which established the foundation for regulating police training across the state.
That law was amended in February of 2021 when a new qualification was added, dictating that anyone who wants to run for Sheriff in Illinois must have:
“a certificate attesting to his or her successful completion of the Minimum Standards Basic Law Enforcement Officers Training Course as prescribed by the Illinois Law Enforcement Training Standards Board, or a substantially similar training program of another state or the federal government.”
After attending a part-time police academy course, Sands was issued an equivalency exam to waive out of this requirement, which he passed in 1996.

Sands’ failure to file Full Packet before deadline
Despite holding the waiver, Hawker argued that Sands’ petition should still be rejected because he hadn’t submitted any proof of this waiver along with his packet to run for sheriff by the deadline, which was Monday, Nov. 3.
For his part, Sands claimed he was unaware of the requirement to submit the waiver until Friday, October 31, and that when he reached out to the Illinois Police Training Standards Board office to request the document, he was told they couldn’t find it.
“I got kind of the run-around from the training board that it was a Friday, and they said, ‘Well, we don’t have any record to you taking it.’ They couldn’t find it, but they ended up finding it the next day,” Sands said.
Ultimately, the IPTSB office did find the documentation and send it via email to both Sands and the Vermilion County Clerk’s office on Tuesday, November 4 — a full day after the official deadline to file his election petition.
Precedential Cases Cited
To substantiate his right to be included on the ballot, Sands cited the August 2022 case of Brogan v. Colatorti, in which Antonio “Tony” Colatorti’s petition to run as Sheriff of McHenry county was upheld after being challenged for the same reason as Sands.
In that case, the court held that Colatorti was qualified for the office of sheriff, ruling that his part‑time certificate, along with the evidence of training and service, satisfied the statutory requirement for the certificate.
Colatorti’s case had similar points in common with Sands’, including that both men were issued a certificate from the Illinois Law Enforcement Training and Standards Board, both had previously been employed as law enforcement officers but were currently considered “inactive,” and both men failed to submit proof of their certification when they filed their paperwork.
Still, Vermilion County State’s Attorney and member of the board Jacqueline Lacy argued that Colatorti’s case didn’t apply as a precedent in Sands’ case, only as a “persuasive case.”
“That appellate court opinion [ruling in favor of Colatorti] is not speaking about a correctional officer. That appellate court opinion is speaking specifically regarding law enforcement minimum training,” Lacy said.
Ultimately, the Board sided with Hawker, who cited the case of Gercone v. Cook County Officers Electoral Board, another case from 2022.
In that case, the Illinois Appellate Court ruled that Carmen Navarro Gercone was unqualified when she filed to run for Sheriff.
Notably, the decision regarding Gercone, like other Illinois appellate court decisions, is filed under Illinois Supreme Court Rule 23, meaning the opinion is non-precedential, except under limited exceptions outlined in Rule 23(e)(1).
Those rules dictate that no legal ruling can cite cases like Gercone’s case as a precedent unless, 1. it is relevant to a procedural history involving res judicata or law of the case, 2. a party is showing diligence in pursuing a related claim, 3. someone is trying to demonstrate appellate inconsistency on similar issues, Or 4. it is later published under Rule 23(f).
Like Colatorti’s case, Gercone’s case can only be considered by a legal body in Illinois as a persuasive case, not a precedential one.
Sands’ Claim He Was Unaware of Certification Requirement
Lacy also pointed out that when Sands signed and submitted his intention to run for office, he was also claiming he held legal eligibility to do so.
“The statement of candidacy specifically says, ‘to be voted upon at the primary election on 3/17/2026, and that I am legally qualified’ and then in parentheses it says, ‘including being the holder of any license that may be an eligibility requirement for the office to which I seek the nomination,’” Lacy said.

For Sands’ part, he thought he was qualified, he said, based on holding the waiver. He also said he didn’t know the certification was a requirement to run until that Friday, October 31, when he reached out to the appropriate office.
During closing remarks, Melissa Quick, Vermilion County Circuit Clerk, said it was Sands’ responsibility to know what was required of him.
“I feel like when you’re running for office that it is your obligation to read the statue and know what’s required in order to fulfill that position,” Quick said. “It’s your due diligence to find out what exactly you need, to make sure you have all your i’s dotted and your t’s crossed when you file that nomination petition.”
The Letter of the Law vs. The Spirit of the Law
A central topic at the heart of the discussion was whether or not the spirit of the law should be taken into consideration alongside the letter of the law.
“My understanding of the spirit of the law is they don’t want a plumber to run for sheriff,” Sands said.
But Lacy said the spirit of the law wasn’t being considered.
“When you look at the statutory requirements to run for sheriff, it law in Illinois requires strict compliance. It’s about the four corners of the document. It’s not about the spirit of the law,” Lacy said.
Reactions to Ruling
Sands said he felt he was not given a fair chance.
“Their decision was already made before we got here,” Sands said after the meeting adjourned. “Two of the three people that voted already rejected my petition before I even tried to turn it in.”
According to Sands, when he attempted to submit his petition to run for Sheriff, his petition was rejected because some in the office felt he was unqualified. Sands then appealed to the State Election Board, he said, who forced them to accept his petition, saying it was not within their right sot reject anyone who applied to run.
The third person on the board was Robyn Heffern, Vermilion County Clerk — one of the two who attempted to reject his petition.
Quick, who graduated from high school with Sands, said she was disappointed but ultimately stands by her decision to vote against Sands’ petition.
“You never want to see anybody to taken off of a ballot. That’s what we’re here for, to give voters a chance to make informed decision,” Quick said.
“Unfortunately, by not meeting that statue, knowing what he had to have it on file in advance and not having everything he needed on file, he left us with no decision but to take him off the ballot,” she added.
As to why he had intended to run for sheriff, Sands said he hoped to see a cultural shift.
“I think it’s time for a cultural change,” he said. After the meeting, he said the ruling and the politics surrounding it, in his opinion, are exactly what needs to change.
Sands also said he believed the board was prejudiced against him.
“It’s all politics,” he said.
Sands was the only Democrat running for the office of sheriff.
Also in attendance was Amy Buttram, Head of the Democratic Party in Vermilion County, who agreed with Sands.
“I think that they definitely want to keep off anyone that’s not a Republican that’s running. I’m actually shocked that they were allowing two candidates to run on the Republican party ticket,” Buttram said.
“The law states that he has to prove that, yes, he is certified to be a sheriff candidate. There is nothing in the law that states he had to have all of his documentation filed that day. It just says that he has made a statement saying that he is qualified. And he believed he was,” Buttram added.
Sands said he intends to appeal the board’s ruling. According to state law, he has five (5) days to file an appeal with the Danville Election Commission, made up of three people: Thomas J. Mellen, Frank R. Young, and Catherine (Katie) Osterbur.

