Tag: justice for Cali

  • “Scared. Worried. Sad. Mad.” – 10 y.o. sibling of murdered toddler testifies

    “Scared. Worried. Sad. Mad.” – 10 y.o. sibling of murdered toddler testifies

    On the first day of the jury trial of Dantrail Johnson, charged with first-degree murder in the 2022 death of two-year-old Cali Marie Sago, the prosecution focused on highlighting Cali Marie’s injuries, Johnson’s past, and conflicting aspects of Johnson’s story.

    Photo of Cali Marie Sago, courtesy of Danielle Madlock, grandmother.

    Cali Marie had “50+ injuries”

    Day one began with the prosecution calling Child Abuse Pediatrics expert Dr. Channing Petrak to the stand. Petrak was one of the consulting physicians caring for Sago in the last month of her life at Peoria Children’s Hospital. She specializes in caring for children who are suspected of having been victims of child abuse.

    Petrak testified for more than an hour, sharing details of the 50+ injuries Sago had when she arrived at the pediatric ICU. As Petrak spoke, the prosecution showed around 40 images of the injuries on Sago’s body in the ICU, where she was ventilated to keep her breathing.

    Aside from lacerations all across her body, Sago presented with multiple loop-shaped bruises and scars, which could only have been caused by intentional infliction, Petrak said. There were also patterned injuries, consistent with Cali Marie being hit with items.

    According to Petrak, such injuries are suspected to have been caused by child abuse when they present in odd places where children are not likely to injure themselves through playing or falling or even play-fighting with other children — places like the buttocks, under the armpits, and on the back.

    A later autopsy revealed Cali Marie’s liver and pancreas were damaged, and she had several broken ribs.

    Ultimately, it was a traumatic brain injury, caused by “extremely violent” blunt force trauma that killed the two-year-old — trauma more damaging than that seen in children who have fallen from a two-storey window, Petrak said.

    Only a significant, rapid acceleration-deceleration to the head could cause such damage to the brain, “magnitudes” worse than that seen in a concussion victim, Petrak testified.

    Defense attorney Mike Mara declined to cross-examine the witness.

    Johnson accused of history of child abuse

    Dominique Perry, Johnson’s former partner, also testified for the prosecution about an injury their son, Noah, received from Johnson when he was six months old.

    Perry testified that one night in 2016, while they were homeless and staying in a motel, Noah kept repeatedly pulling his pacifier out of his mouth. Perry said that Johnson, in an attempt to keep Noah from pulling the pacifier out of his mouth, swaddled their son “very tight” — so hard, in fact, that he broke both of Noah’s arms, she alleges.

    When asked by the prosecution how Johnson reacted or whether he encouraged her to take Noah to a hospital, Perry claimed she “did not remember.”

    Perry claims to have had no contact with Johnson since around 2020. Their son Noah is 10 years old now.

    The defense declined to cross-examine Perry.

    “She was scared of him,” Sibling says of Johnson

    The next to speak was a minor, one of Sago’s older siblings, who was present in the room the night Sago became unresponsive.

    After asking the minor several light questions to ensure she was comfortable, like what her favorite subject in school and her favorite song, Assistant Attorney General Michael Falagario asked the minor to tell the jury what happened on August 11, 2022.

    According to the minor — who referred to Johnson as “my stepdad, Buck,” — after her mom, Olly Lightfoot, went to work at Flex n Gate around noon that day, she and her three siblings spent the day playing and watching t.v.

    Cali Marie Sago poses for a photo. Photo courtesy of grandmother Danielle Madlock

    For a while, the minor said she and Sago played a game of tag and freeze tag. Then, the two sat with their other siblings watching t.v. At one point, the minor said, Johnson became aware that Sago was sucking her thumb — something he would often punish her for.

    The minor testified that Johnson approached the siblings, then punched Sago “hard” on the top of her head, bringing his fist down, then punched her under the chin, bringing his fist up — something the minor acted out on the stand.

    She said Sago began acting strangely shortly afterward, sleepy and lethargic, then went to lie down with the minor on her bed and watch t.v.

    Some time later, the minor said, Johnson came into the room to make sure the kids ate dinner. That’s when he picked Sago up and carried her to the bathroom, wearing only a diaper, and placed her face under the shower head in an attempt to wake her up, Johnson told police.

    The minor claimed to have seen, from her bedroom, into the bathroom when Johnson placed Sago repeatedly into and out of the shower, before eventually attempting CPR and calling 911.

    The minor, who was only six years old at the time, recalls trying to get her other siblings’ attention but failing, then pacing in the living room as Johnson performed CPR. She said she was whispering to herself repeatedly, “He better not have killed my baby sister.”

    The minor also testified that Sago was typically “scared” of Johnson and would not act herself around him, which was playful and nice, she said.

    When asked how she felt in those moments, the minor said, “Scared. Worried. Sad,” and later, when she had to sit right next to Johnson in the back of the police car to the station to be interviewed, “Scared. Worried. Mad.”

    Johnson changes story in police interviews

    Next, the prosecution called Detective Dawn Hartshorn to the stand. Hartshorn, along with detective Brandon Hahn, interviewed Lightfoot and her children, as well as Johnson, at the Danville Police Department the night Sago was found unconscious.

    Hartshorn said Johnson told her he had placed Sago into the water again and again because he believed she was in shock and the water might revive her.

    When asked how he and Lightfoot would discipline the children when they were in trouble, Hartshorn said Johnson denied either of them using physical punishment. He claimed Lightfoot would just yell at the kids or put them in a corner when they misbehaved.

    He also said he wouldn’t hit the kids because they weren’t his “biological children.” The two had only been dating for around six months when Sago went to the hospital. Johnson had been watching the kids so Lightfoot could go to work.

    But several hours later, when Hartshorn asked whether Lightfoot ever “whooped” the kids, Johnson said yes, she did. Hartshorn also claimed Johnson had become much more “aggressive” in his interactions with her during the later interview.

    The prosecution called several police officers to the stand, each telling their version of the story of what happened when they arrived at the Lightfoot home, finding Sago lying unconscious and naked on the living room floor, while Johnson frantically walked around the house, repeatedly claiming he didn’t do anything to Sago.

    The trial continues Thursday, January 29, when the prosecution is set to have Lightfoot herself on the stand to testify against Johnson.


    Help support independent journalism

    The Vermilion Times is an independent, 501 (c)(3) nonprofit media organization, run by two journalists who are dedicated to informing and empowering the people of Vermilion County.

    We believe people shouldn’t have to pay to be informed about what’s happening in their community. That’s why we don’t charge a fee to read our stories or listen to our podcast episodes.

    Your donations, no matter how small, help us continue to provide high-quality, in-depth stories.