Tag: Ed Butler

  • No Police Brutality in Shakira Logan Case, says NAACP President

    No Police Brutality in Shakira Logan Case, says NAACP President

    After viewing police body cam footage, Edward Butler, President of the Danville chapter of the NAACP, says Danville Police Department officers were justified in their treatment of Shakira Logan — a pregnant Black woman who was recorded being dragged across grass and asphalt by DPD officers on August 15, 2025.

    A recording made by an onlooker, which showed only the latter half of the incident, was uploaded to social media and went viral causing public outcry.

    For their part, the City of Danville, including Mayor Rickey Williams, Jr and Police Chief Christopher Yates, have maintained that officers were acting in self-defense and that this was not a case of police brutality.

    In September, The Vermilion Times filed a FOIA request for body cam footage of the arrest to get a better understanding of the incident, but our request was denied, citing an ongoing investigation.

    In his capacity as president of the local NAACP chapter, Butler and a colleague were allowed to view the footage from Logan’s arrest, at the behest of Yates.

    Logan Maces Another Woman

    On the night of Logan’s arrest, police were in the Green Meadows neighborhood following an unrelated call that had just concluded, according to Yates.

    “Area residents approached officers and advised them that a fight was getting started between two females, one being Ms. Logan,” Yates said. “Ms. Logan did not call the police.”

    Upon arrival, officers found that “an altercation in which another female was pepper-sprayed” had just occurred, Yates said.

    Police were also told that an unknown minor may have been sprayed as well, though Yates said this could not be confirmed.

    “No police brutality”

    According to Butler, body cam footage shows that DPD officers asked Logan repeatedly to stand up and walk to the police car.

    “They approached her and told her she was under arrest for aggravated battery,” Butler said. “At that point, she just dropped to the ground and folded her arms because she didn’t want to go to jail.”

    After Logan dropped to the ground, police began attempting to unfold her arms so they could handcuff her, Butler said, at which point she curled into the fetal position and began fighting back.

    “There were four officers trying to get her up off the ground,” Butler said. “She bit one of the officers on the hand, then she kicked another in the mouth and another in the chest.”

    During this altercation with police, there was an increasingly larger crowd gathering, including some teens and children who were attempting to get past police to hurt Logan, Butler said.

    Making matters worse, the incident took place against the exterior wall of a residential building, so the police also felt they were outnumbered and in danger, Butler said.

    “As a matter of fact, I saw one of the kids was pushing the officers,” he added.

    In an attempt to remove themselves and Logan from danger, Butler said, police decided to drag her away from the crowd across a field of grass.

    Once they got to the asphalt parking lot, police dragged her up and over a parking block, which can be seen in the publically-shared video.

    Away from the crowd, police were able to get her into handcuffs, and they again asked her several times to stand up, but she still refused.

    That’s when someone informed police that Logan was pregnant, at which point they called paramedics, Butler said.

    “Once the paramedics arrived, they asked her against to stand up so they could load her onto the gurney, and she did,” Butler said. Logan was then taken to the hospital to be treated before she was taken to jail, Butler said.

    In Butler’s opinion, DPD officers could have perhaps done better.

    “Could they have done something better? I’m sure that they could have, besides drag her across the lawn. it doesn’t look good on their part,” Butler said.

    At the same time, Butler said, he recognizes they had few options.

     “They could have let her lay there in harm’s way and let people come in and kick her and all that stuff, and it would have been a whole lot worse,” Butler said.

    “Things would have really gotten out of hand. The police would have been at fault if they left her there. It’s just a hard decision to make,” Butler said.

    In his opinion, none of it would have happened had Logan simply obeyed the law and not resisted arrest.

    “We, as the people, need to adhere to the law, and when the police ask us to do something we need to obey and do what the officers ask us to do, not only to protect ourselves but to protect others, too,” Butler said.

    The State’s Case Against Logan

    The investigation into Logan’s actions that night has been concluded, unless Lacy’s office makes a request for additional information, Yates said in an email to the Vermilion Times on October 13.

    Logan received four charges of aggravated battery against an officer and one charge of aggravated battery in a public place for kicking officers, one of which she kicked in the face and drew blood, according to the footage, Butler said.

    Logan also received one charge of filing a false alarm by calling 911 without reason. It’s unclear what this concerns, since Yates asserts police weren’t called to the scene but brought over by concerned locals.

    This isn’t the first time Logan has run into trouble with the law. In 2010, she was charged with resisting or obstructing a peace officer — a criminal misdemeanor. She made a plea deal in that case.

    Logan was charged with another criminal misdemeanor in 2023 when she again resisted arrest and harmed a police officer.

    In 2024, she was charged with battery that caused bodily harm. In that case, she was released from custody to await trial, but after being charged with new felonies in the August 15 incident, her release was revoked.

    According to court records, on June 23 Logan entered a “not guilty” plea, and the case was set for pre-trial. Before that court date arrived, though, Logan was arrested on another, separate case, and attended her next court date via video on August 15.

    Due to the new case against her, Logan’s pretrial release was revoked and she was kept in custody. There were two more court dates since then, both of which Logan attended via video, as she remains in custody.

    Logan’s next pre-trial court date is set for 11/17/25 at 9:00 a.m. in courtroom 3B at the Vermilion County Courthouse, where Honorable Judge Karen Wall will be presiding.

    DPD Human Resources Investigation

    Though the case is closed regarding the charges against Logan, Yates said the body cam footage of her arrest cannot be released to the public yet due to Lacy’s ongoing prosecution of Logan, as well as a Human Relations investigation into the actions of the officers on scene.

    “The officers at the scene and their actions were investigated and reviewed for any violations of departmental policy and statutes as required by the complaint,” Yates said, referring to a complaint which was filed by Logan.

    The Vermilion Times was unable to reach Logan for comment.