UPDATE: Illinois State Police deny FOIA request
At this time, investigations into Vermillion County Treasurer Darren Duncan are still ongoing.
The Illinois State Police’s Public Corruption Department denied our FOIA request for records regarding allegations that, in 2025, Duncan attempted to coerce a resigned precinct committee person into hiding her resignation so she could vote against now-County Clerk Robyn Heffern.
“ISP is still actively investigating this case. Releasing the information at this time would compromise the investigation. ISP is awaiting additional documents, as well as outstanding interviews,” the denial letter reads. “Any release would greatly hamper any potential witnesses, collection of evidence, or other investigative activities.”
We will follow up on this story later in the year, ahead of the general election in November, when Duncan is running unopposed after beating Republican challenger Jason Whaling in the primary election.
Text Messages Show county treasurer urged a former precinct official to Hide Her Resignation until after a vote to appoint a new county clerk
In a May 14, 2025 exchange, Vermilion County Treasurer Darren Duncan acknowledged that Mary Surprenant-Lovejoy had already informed county officials that she had moved out of her precinct and tendered her resignation — but Duncan suggested that only he and County Auditor Erika Ramsey knew about it and that they had “held that off for now.”
“We’d like to convince you to hold off until you cast a vote for Cathy [Jenkins’] replacement,” Duncan wrote.
But Surprenant-Lovejoy had emailed her resignation to Ramsey two months earlier, in March 2025, after moving out of Precinct 17 following the end of her marriage — something she was legally required to do.
According to Illinois Election Law 10 ILCS 5/7-8, when an elected official moves out of the area they were elected to represent, their seat becomes immediately vacated by law.

Two months later, when it was time to appoint a new County Clerk after the retirement of former County Clerk Cathy Jenkins, Duncan reached out to Surprenant-Lovejoy via text, asking her for help with “something political.”
After Surprenant-Lovejoy advised him she was no longer a Precinct Committeeperson, Duncan said he knew she had informed Erika of her move and intent to resign, but said he believed Surprenant-Lovejoy could still “help me with the county clerk position” that was up for appointment.
When Surprenant-Lovejoy again reiterated that she had already resigned from her position in writing, Duncan advised her that“only Erika and I know that and she and I have held that off for now.”
“We’d like to convince you to hold off until you cast a vote for Cathy [Jenkin]’s replacement,” Duncan said.
“It’s done, Darren,” Surprenant-Lovejoy said, ending the exchange.

VC Officials Already Under Investigation
Several VC officials are already under investigation after Mike Marron, former CEO of Vermilion Advantage resigned, accusing some officials of misconduct, specifically pertaining to the County Clerk election.
Marron shared a series of text message exchanges between himself and Duncan that appear to show Duncan accusing Chairman Steve Miller of attempting to bribe elected officials.
In one text conversation, which took place on Friday, May 30, Duncan told Marron that Miller had promised Board members “money and county board seats” in exchange for votes in the County Clerk election.
In that exchange, Marron reached out, asking Duncan how “the committee meeting” went. After informing Marron that Robyn Heffern had won the County Clerk seat, Duncan then cited specifics of what was promised by Miller in exchange for votes: “$12k to Potomac FD (Fire Department) for Gary Hawker” and “CB2 (District 2 Seat) to Eric Luttrell.”
HR Complaints Against Duncan Surface
On March 4, 2026, several days before Surprenant-Lovejoy posted the screenshot of the text message exchange with Duncan on her personal Facebook page, The Vermilion Times received an anonymous email containing several documents that seemed to be records of HR complaints filed against Duncan, though their authenticity has not yet been verified through the County’s HR department.
Some of the complaints, which seem to have been filed by several different employees across a five year period, pertained to what VC Treasurer’s Office H.R. Rep Nancy Boose referred to in one email as Duncan’s creating what could be called a “hostile work environment.”
In one complaint, filed in November 2023, Heffern — who won the County Clerk appointment after all — told Boose that she felt “physically ill” when Duncan entered her office.
“[Heffern] said [Duncan] has harassed, threatened, and discriminated against her because she is a woman,” the complaint reads.
See the full complaint, and Duncan’s response, below.
Another employee, Ashley Imke, walked off the job in late March, claiming Duncan, “would ask them all to go out for drinks after work, and if they don’t go out or don’t coddle him, then you aren’t being loyal to him.”
She also described a work environment in which County employees would have to “walk on eggshells” when Duncan was in the office because, “they don’t know his mood and which Darren they were going to get at a given moment.”
Another common thread in the complaints was Duncan’s use of public humiliation against his employees.
Heffern refered to instances in which Duncan would publically criticize her, while Imke described feeling “uncomfortable” when Duncan “treated Rhonda [McGowan] badly in front of everyone.”
Eventually, Ashley said she left because she “does not feel ok… and has had to defend employees when Darren would pick on them,” because “anytime someone stands up for themselves to Darren, things got worse for them and he treated them worse.”
One such fellow employee Imke worried about was Kendra Edwards, who resigned around the same time Imke did and filed a mutual complaint with Imke.
In that complaint, both women complained of Duncan treating some employees with favoritism, as well as throwing a document at Edwards to embarass her and advising her she needed to “think about what kind of person she is” to ask to leave work early.
An aside
Since the email containing the above mentioned documents was sent by an anonymous source, The Vermilion Times began the process of due diligence.
On Thursday, March 5, The Vermilion Times reached out to Duncan for comment regarding the HR complaint documents.
Though we gave him until Tuesday, March 10 to respond, in light of Surprenant-Lovejoy’s text exchange, we decided to move forward with the story. Should Duncan respond later, we will update this story.
Vermilion County Watchdog Advises VT Not To Publish Documents
Over the course of several days after we received the anonymous email, Alec Severins, founder of Vermilion County Watchdog, reached out to the Vermilion Times several times by phone and text message to advise us not to publish the HR complaint documents, claiming it would “look like election interference” for us to share them so close to the election, especially considering our nonprofit status.
Severins said he was told about the complaints in late 2025 and he filed a FOIA request with the County. He then published the documents in a social media post lambasting Duncan.
That post has since been taken down by Severins.

Severins also told the Vermilion Times that he had deleted the post about Duncan because he had come to the conclusion that the HR complaints were not credible, mostly in light of his perspective of Edwards, whom he referred to as a “disgruntled employee” of Duncan’s who was simply trying to get her boyfriend, challenger Jason Whaling, elected by sending the anonymous email to several news organizations so close to the election.
Severins also claimed Edwards had recently drunkenly slandered him by accusing him of taking a bribe.

In an apparent attempt to question Edwards’ credibility, Severins also shared audio of a 911 call, placed by Whaling’s daughter, wherein she is heard crying and asking for an officer to be sent to the home because her parents are arguing.
TW: Domestic dispute, minor under emotional duress
The story about the 911 call has been shared by other news outlets previously, with some claiming the woman the caller says is her mother in the recording was her biological mother, Whaling’s now-ex wife.
But in a social media post, Edwards said it was her arguing with Whaling, not his ex-wife.
Surprenant-Lovejoy Reports Duncan to Illinois State Police
After seeing a news story about the HR complaints in October 2025, Surprenant-Lovejoy said she decided to reach out to the Illinois State Police’s Public Corruption department to report Duncan’s text message to her.
Surprenant-Lovejoy says she never heard back from the ISP regarding the investigation.
The Vermilion Times has filed a FOIA Request with the ISP for documents and internal communications pertaining to Surprenant-Lovejoy’s complaint. They have five business days to respond, but could ask for another five days, according to the Freedom of Information Act.
This story will be updated as new facts emerge.
Help support independent journalism
The Vermilion Times is an independent, 501 (c)(3) nonprofit media organization, run by two journalists who are dedicated to informing and empowering the people of Vermilion County.
We believe people shouldn’t have to pay to be informed about what’s happening in their community. That’s why we don’t charge a fee to read our stories or listen to our podcast episodes.
Your donations, no matter how small, help us continue to provide high-quality, in-depth stories.
Have something to say?
Your voice matters. The Vermilion Times is always seeking new perspectives to share, whether as opinion pieces, articles, or podcast discussions. Drop us a line!


Leave a Reply